What to ask a LinkedIn outreach agency before you hire one
Five questions that show whether a LinkedIn outreach agency will get you meetings, and what a good answer sounds like, from real campaign benchmarks.

Five questions tell you most of what you need to know. Each has an answer you can check against real campaigns, and each one finds a place where campaigns lose meetings without anyone noticing.
The figures below are benchmarks: what real campaigns achieved, measured across every campaign on our platform. The full research behind each one is linked as you go.
Your agency scorecard
0 of 5 good answers
Tick each one as the agency answers it well. Nothing is saved.
1. "How do you continuously optimise to make sure campaigns get the best possible results?"
The gap between a typical campaign and a great one is real. In a typical campaign, 37% of connection requests were accepted. In the best quarter, 47% or more. Ask how the agency closes that gap.
Measured changes move the numbers. In real campaigns, acting on the targeting analysis took acceptance from 39% to 48%, and acting on the reply analysis took reply rates from 22% to 24%.
A good process works on both who you contact and what you say, because the quarter of campaigns with the highest acceptance replied about as often as the rest.
A good answer: a regular cycle that changes who you contact and what you say, based on what the data shows.
2. "To what extent do you report results?"
LinkedIn profiles sent about 74% of the volume they were set up for, roughly three-quarters. A restricted account is loud. A quiet one is just quiet, and the sending tools only show what went out. More on why accounts send less than you think.
So a good report starts with requests sent against the target, then acceptances, replies and meetings. And it puts benchmarks beside them, so you know whether a number is good.
A good answer: every week, requests sent against target, acceptances, replies and meetings, with benchmarks beside them.
3. "How do you help with reply management?"
Most meetings start with a reply that isn't a clear yes: 71% of them, in real campaigns. Yet 42% of the replies worth answering never got a message back. We explain what each kind of reply means in What LinkedIn replies mean.
Speed counts too. Replies answered within the hour became meetings about one and a half times as often as replies answered later. A first answer within the hour that suggested a time booked a meeting 25% of the time, about one in four. Yet the middle reply waited about half a day for an answer, and more than a day at the weekend. More on how fast to reply.
A good answer: they can answer your replies for you, quickly and with a time suggested. If you'd rather keep replies in-house, they tell you what to answer with and when, and alert you when a promising reply is missed.
4. "What rates do your campaigns get, and how is the reply rate counted?"
In a typical campaign, 37% of connection requests were accepted, and 25% of the people messaged replied. The best quarter of campaigns reached 47% and 31%.
Then ask what the reply rate is counted against. Counted against every request sent, the same typical campaign reads about 8%. Both are fair, but you can only compare agencies that count the same way. More on reply rates.
A good answer: rates near these benchmarks, with the reply rate counted against the people messaged.
5. "Where does outreach lose meetings, and how do you plug each leak?"
Outreach leaks meetings at every stage, from launch to learning who responds best. Our homepage draws them all as one pipe. Ask the agency to walk you through every one, and tick it off when they show you how they plug it.
Your leak checklist
0 of 8 plugged
Before launch
While sending
When they reply
Every two months
Every leak from our homepage diagram, in the order a campaign meets them. Tick each one the agency can show you it plugs.
A good answer: a clear answer for every leak on the list.
What this means for your firm
A good agency will be glad you asked. Every one of these questions has a clear answer, and the answers tell you more than any case study.
Want us to run it for you?
Here is how we answer. On our Done For You Optimised plan, we run a full improvement cycle every two months, tuning who we contact and what we say. Every week you get a report: requests sent, acceptances, replies and meetings in motion, with benchmarks beside them.
For replies, we offer Setter Squad: we answer every reply the way an expert setter would, and steer it towards a meeting. If you'd rather answer your own, our Optimised plan gives you insights on what to answer with and when, and alerts you when a promising reply is missed.
Every leak on the list is plugged by one of our plans, and the homepage shows which.
Book a call, bring the scorecard, and ask us all five.


